Picking the perfect vacation destination can involve a lot of pro and con list making. Two of the most popular New England spots both reside off the southern coast of Cape Cod. Both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard have been attracting countless vacationers for years, and for good reason. However, there are differences between these two Massachusetts hot spots. To help you in your decision-making process, the Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites team has put together a Martha’s Vineyard vs. Nantucket cheat sheet.
The Differences
One of the first main differences between these two islands is their size. Martha’s Vineyard is almost twice the size of Nantucket, measuring in at 96 square miles. Because of its larger size, Martha’s Vineyard is home to several towns, each with their own unique personality. While both islands are home to stunning scenery, there are noticeable differences in what you can expect to see. Martha’s Vineyard features rolling hills and high cliffs, while Nantucket is flatter. If you’re looking to spend time on the beach, both New England spots are home to incredible beaches. However, because of its larger size, there is more coastline on Martha’s Vineyard. Some of the best beaches near our Edgartown hotel include Lighthouse Beach and South Beach, which are the perfect places to enjoy incredible beach activities.The Similarities
While the two islands have plenty of differences, there are also several similarities.- Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard are great places to enjoy outdoor activities, like kayak tours with Island Spirit Kayak through Martha’s Vineyard waterways.
- Both are home to lighthouses that serve as landmarks to their maritime past, including the Edgartown Lighthouse.
- Summer is the main tourist season.
- Both are great to explore on bike rentals, like those available to our guests or from local shops like Edgartown Bicycles.
- Both are the perfect destination for everyone, from families to couples looking to make lifelong memories.
Plan Your Martha’s Vineyard Vacation
As a boutique hotel in Edgartown, our vote in the Martha’s Vineyard vs. Nantucket debate will always be Martha’s Vineyard. See for yourself why we feel our New England island is the better vacation destination by planning a memorable visit.
Overlooking the Edgartown harbor, our hotel is the perfect home base for your stay. Be close to all that makes this area unique while having a relaxing place to call home. We offer several accommodation styles, which means you can choose the one that fits your group best. Learn more about our hotel and Martha’s Vineyard by calling 508-627-4711. We can also answer questions about current special offers.
It can sometimes be hard to figure out when to book your stay at 
As the new year gets underway, now is the perfect time to plan your stay with Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites. After reserving your 
Adventure is right at your fingertips when you book your stay at 
If you’re looking for more recommendations of what to see in Martha’s Vineyard, stop by the front desk at Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites. Our 
The New England region is filled with breathtaking scenery, and some of the best examples of Mother Nature’s work can be found on Martha’s Vineyard. Enjoy waterfront views by reserving your stay at 
Whether you’re planning a fun-filled 
Once a major whaling port in the 1800s, Edgartown is now a charming spot perfect for anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Located in the heart of this Martha’s Vineyard town is 
When on vacation, you want to be as relaxed as possible. Enjoy luxurious accommodations in a relaxing setting by booking your stay at Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites. Found in the historic waterfront district, our hotel puts you near all the adventures you could ever want. Take advantage of transportation options like the bus on Martha’s Vineyard, and let someone else worry about getting you from Point A to Point B. 
