The Best Places to Eat on Martha’s Vineyard for Sweet Treats

A person stocking the bakery case at one of the best places to eat on Martha's Vineyard for something sweet.

Not only is Martha’s Vineyard home to an abundance of adventure, but it is also home to an incredible culinary scene. From charming local coffee shops to a delicious food and wine festival, the New England island is the perfect foodie escape. If you’re craving something sweet during your stay at Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites, you’re in luck. You can easily find an array of sweet treats like ice cream, chocolate, and more near our Edgartown hotel. To help you satisfy your cravings, we’ve compiled a list of the best places to eat on Martha’s Vineyard for when your sweet tooth strikes.

Many of the spots on our guide are open seasonally. Remember to check their websites or call ahead if it’s early or late in the season to confirm their hours.

Where to Find Ice Cream

If you’re staying with us over the summer, cool off with a cup, cone, or sundae from a nearby ice cream shop. The Scoop Shack is known for its small-batch creations, while Mad Martha’s has been a Martha’s Vineyard staple since 1971. For a quick yet delicious option, check out Vineyard Scoops, found only a few blocks from our Edgartown hotel.

Where to Find All Kinds of Goodies

For a variety of treats all in one place, check out some of the decadent bakeries on Martha’s Vineyard. Rosewater Cafe has an extensive selection of scratch-made baked goods. Espresso Love is a great place to relax with a cup of coffee and a sweet treat like a cookie or a Magic Bar. If your ferry ride ends at Vineyard Haven, stop by Sweet Bites to grab something to enjoy when you get to our hotel.

Where to Find Creamy Chocolate

Martha’s Vineyard is also home to several places that satisfy any chocolate craving you may have. Mudrick’s Fudge has a case full of decadent fudge in a range of flavors, while Enchanted Chocolates in Oak Bluffs has everything from chocolate-covered espresso beans to chocolate bars.

Treat Yourself on a Martha’s Vineyard Escape

The bedroom of a Martha's Vineyard hotel close to some of the best sweet places to eat.

Stopping by some of the best places to eat for sweets on Martha’s Vineyard isn’t the only way to treat yourself on vacation. When booking your stay at Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites, reserve one of our luxury rooms. These accommodations offer extra privacy and relaxation. Relax watching the sunset from your private balcony, or relax in your spa-like bathroom. Learn more about this lodging style or other accommodations at our hotel in Edgartown by calling 508-627-4711. Be sure to ask about our special offers!

The Best Places to Eat on Martha’s Vineyard for Sweet Treats
Celebrate the 50th Anniversary of Jaws on Martha’s Vineyard
Fuel Up at a Martha’s Vineyard Coffee Shop
Embrace Spring in Massachusetts | Spend Time Outdoors
What to Do on Martha’s Vineyard on a Gloomy Day