TripAdvisor Logo.

Edgartown Hotel Dining Guide

Edgartown Restaurants and Martha’s Vineyard Dining

There are almost as many fabulous restaurants on Martha’s Vineyard as there are beautiful beaches. No matter what fare you fancy during your Martha’s Vineyard getaway, our knowledgeable staff can point you in the right direction.

Whether it’s a take out clambake for the beach, a microbrewery visit to Oak Bluffs , or an intimate dinner by candlelight right here in Edgartown, we can help arrange a Martha’s Vineyard dining experience to suit your mood. Here are some of our most popular walking-distance hot spots (complete with concierge tips!) to help you with your pre-visit research:


71 Main St
Bistro and bar. Total comfort food.
Concierge tip: 
We have a soft spot for the Risotto Balls on the bar menu!
Map It

Among the Flowers Café

17 Mayhew Lane
Seasonal, fantastic breakfast, good lunch for dine in or take out.
Concierge tip: 
Great bet for good affordable dinners in July and August
Map It

Atlantic Fish and Chop House

2 Main St
Great food, music and dancing in summer, upscale harbor-front fun
Concierge tip: 
Awesome location right on Edgartown Harbor

Map It


Right here at Vineyard Square! Click here for details or visit their website.
Concierge tip: Remember to leave room for dessert – we can’t resist the Snowball!


15 Winter St
Bistro fine dining with an intimate atmosphere. Top Zagat-rated restaurant.
Concierge tip: 
Menu very seasonal and fresh, great wine list

Map It

Espresso Love

17 Church St
Coffee heaven and the Vineyard Square Hotel team’s second home! Great baked goods and sandwiches, too.
Concierge tip: 
You can’t go wrong with the Katama Chicken Sandwich on fresh-baked foccacia and the White Chocolate Heath Bar cookies

Map It


22 North Water St
Fabulous fine dining, amazing service, more informal bar area for light bites and cocktails.
Concierge tip: 
Try their signature ‘Startini’ — yum!

Map It

The Newes from America Pub

23 Kelly St
Brews, Burgers, Sandwiches
Concierge tip:
 Try the French Onion Soup
Map It

Wharf Pub

3 Main St
Family friendly. Lots of variety.
Concierge tip:
 Great spot for live music and dancing in summer — younger crowd, lively atmosphere
Map It

Join Our Mailing List

Stay in the know. Be the first to hear about events and specials.