The Top 7 Edgartown, MA Restaurants for Seafood Lovers

A photo of a couple dining at an Edgartown, MA seafood restaurant.Martha’s Vineyard is full of picturesque beaches, amazing boutiques, and unique charm. It’s also home to a world-class food scene. With close proximity to all of this, Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites is the perfect place to call your home away from home during your getaway. This waterfront town means there’s no shortage of delicious seafood restaurants to dine at while staying at our Edgartown, MA hotel. 


1. Chesca’s Restaurant

Located right off Vineyard Square’s lobby, enjoy fresh seafood and island favorites on our front porch. Blending upscale and comfort foods, Chesca’s has a range of delicious seafood options on its menu, like grilled salmon, grilled rare tuna, and roasted Atlantic cod.

2. Atlantic Fish and Chop House

Dine on the freshest seafood, including branzino, dorado, and wild salmon at Atlantic Fish & Chophouse. You’ll be able to take in the views from the indoor and outdoor seating options while enjoying the elegant yet approachable atmosphere of this Edgartown restaurant.  

3. The Seafood Shanty

For over 50 years, The Seafood Shanty has been serving up fine food and drinks. Enjoy a wide range of scrumptious seafood, like a raw bar, grilled swordfish, sesame pan-seared tuna, and even sushi.  

4. The Wharf

Find out why locals and seasoned visitors return to The Wharf time and time again. Grab a beer on the pub side, or settle into a cozy booth on the restaurant side. No matter which side of the restaurant you dine on, you’ll enjoy fantastic seafood from the lunch menu or dinner menu

5. 19 Raw Oyster Bar

If oysters are your thing, you have to stop at 19 Raw Oyster Bar. While obviously offering an amazing selection of oysters, the seafood doesn’t stop there. The menu is filled with favorites like house-made chowder, tuna carpaccio, charred octopus, and lobster roll.

6. Rockfish Edgartown

Just down the street from our hotel is Rockfish. While known for wood-fired pizza and American bites, the menu is full of delicious seafood options. Dine on fried shrimp and honey garlic sauce, pan-seared sea scallops, or grilled Atlantic swordfish. Don’t forget to pair your meal with a glass of wine or cocktail

7. The Port Hunter

Only open seasonally, The Port Hunter is an Edgartown staple. Start your meal off with Maine mussels and an order of oysters. Select from a range of seafood entrees, including a whole fish, the catch of the day, or fish tacos. You can’t go wrong with whatever you pick from the menu


A photo of the front porch of a hotel near Edgartown, MA restaurants. Enjoy a Coastal Massachusetts Getaway

If you are looking for a quaint and charming town to visit on your next vacation, visit Edgartown. This town on Martha’s Vineyard has everything you need to enjoy a relaxing escape. By booking your stay with Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites, you’ll have an inviting room to unwind in after a day exploring the island. After enjoying a seafood feast at a nearby restaurant, enjoy a night under the stars on our private courtyard or front porch. Learn more about our hotel by calling 508-627-4711

The Best Things to Do in Martha’s Vineyard for Solo Travelers
What to Know about the Martha’s Vineyard African American Film Festival
Plan a Visit to the Martha’s Vineyard Food and Wine Festival
Where to Get the Best Pizza on Martha’s Vineyard Near Edgartown
Explore Memorable Things to Do & See in West Tisbury
Spend a Day at the Manuel F. Correllus State Forest
See the Next Big Thing at a Martha’s Vineyard Film Festival
A Guide on How to Get to Martha’s Vineyard